diff --git a/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementAppointmentController.cs b/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementAppointmentController.cs
index fc25fa13..610b0e7f 100644
--- a/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementAppointmentController.cs
+++ b/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementAppointmentController.cs
@@ -341,7 +341,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
 
                 data.CreatedAt,
                 data.Reason,
-                educationOld = data.EducationOld == "/" || data.EducationOld == null ? null : data.EducationOld,
+                data.EducationOld,
                 data.salary,
                 data.PositionTypeOld,
                 data.PositionLevelOld,
@@ -844,7 +844,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
@@ -1056,7 +1057,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
@@ -1265,7 +1267,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
@@ -1470,7 +1473,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
@@ -1618,13 +1622,13 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
         {
             try
             {
-                 var report_data = (from p in _context.PlacementAppointments
-                                                //.Include(x => x.PlacementEducation)
-                                                // .ThenInclude(x => x.PlacementType)
-                                                .Where(x => req.refIds.Select(x => x.refId).Contains(x.Id.ToString()))
-                                                // .Where(x => x.Placement!.PlacementType!.Name == "เลื่อนข้าราชการ")
-                                                // .Where(x => x.typeCommand.Trim().ToUpper() == "SLIP")
-                                                .ToList()
+                var report_data = (from p in _context.PlacementAppointments
+                                               //.Include(x => x.PlacementEducation)
+                                               // .ThenInclude(x => x.PlacementType)
+                                               .Where(x => req.refIds.Select(x => x.refId).Contains(x.Id.ToString()))
+                                               // .Where(x => x.Placement!.PlacementType!.Name == "เลื่อนข้าราชการ")
+                                               // .Where(x => x.typeCommand.Trim().ToUpper() == "SLIP")
+                                               .ToList()
                                    join r in req.refIds
                                    on p.Id.ToString() equals r.refId
                                    orderby r.Sequence
@@ -1686,7 +1690,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
diff --git a/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementReceiveController.cs b/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementReceiveController.cs
index 33e31c73..731564a2 100644
--- a/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementReceiveController.cs
+++ b/BMA.EHR.Placement.Service/Controllers/PlacementReceiveController.cs
@@ -335,7 +335,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
 
                 data.CreatedAt,
                 data.Reason,
-                educationOld = data.EducationOld == "/" || data.EducationOld == null ? null : data.EducationOld,
+                data.EducationOld,
                 data.AmountOld,
                 data.PositionOld,
                 organizationOld = data.OrganizationOld == "/" || data.OrganizationOld == null ? null : data.OrganizationOld,
@@ -488,7 +488,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Placement.Service.Controllers
                     placementReceive.posLevelOldId = org.result.posLevelId;
                     placementReceive.posLevelNameOld = org.result.posLevelName;
 
-                    // placementReceive.EducationOld = profile.Educations.Count() == 0 ? null : $"{profile.Educations.OrderByDescending(x => x.FinishDate).FirstOrDefault().Degree}-{profile.Educations.OrderByDescending(x => x.FinishDate).FirstOrDefault().Field}";
+                    placementReceive.EducationOld = org.result.education;
                     placementReceive.AmountOld = org.result.Amount;
 
                     placementReceive.PositionOld = org.result.position;
diff --git a/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOtherController.cs b/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOtherController.cs
index 81bc5bce..bcc5d787 100644
--- a/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOtherController.cs
+++ b/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOtherController.cs
@@ -103,7 +103,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service.Controllers
 
                 var retirementOthers = await _context.RetirementOthers.AsQueryable()
                                 .OrderByDescending(x => x.CreatedAt)
-                                .Where(x => rootId == "" ? true : (child1Id == "" ? x.rootOldId == rootId : (child2Id == "" ? x.child1OldId == child1Id : (child3Id == "" ? x.child2OldId == child2Id : (child4Id == "" ? x.child3OldId == child3Id : x.child4OldId == child4Id)))))
+                                // .Where(x => rootId == "" ? true : (child1Id == "" ? x.rootOldId == rootId : (child2Id == "" ? x.child1OldId == child1Id : (child3Id == "" ? x.child2OldId == child2Id : (child4Id == "" ? x.child3OldId == child3Id : x.child4OldId == child4Id)))))
                                 .Select(p => new
                                 {
                                     p.Id,
@@ -721,7 +721,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
@@ -742,7 +743,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service.Controllers
                             CommandExcecuteDate = _null,
                             RemarkHorizontal = _null,
                             RemarkVertical = _null,
-                        }); 
+                        });
                     }
                 }
                 return Success(result);
@@ -927,7 +928,8 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service.Controllers
                 {
                     result.Add(r);
                     string? _null = null;
-                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "") {
+                    if (r.RemarkHorizontal != null && r.RemarkHorizontal != "")
+                    {
                         result.Add(new
                         {
                             No = _null,
diff --git a/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOutController.cs b/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOutController.cs
index 35b274fe..b6468e2b 100644
--- a/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOutController.cs
+++ b/BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service/Controllers/RetirementOutController.cs
@@ -103,7 +103,7 @@ namespace BMA.EHR.Retirement.Service.Controllers
 
                 var retirementOuts = await _context.RetirementOuts.AsQueryable()
                                 .OrderByDescending(x => x.CreatedAt)
-                                .Where(x => rootId == "" ? true : (child1Id == "" ? x.rootOldId == rootId : (child2Id == "" ? x.child1OldId == child1Id : (child3Id == "" ? x.child2OldId == child2Id : (child4Id == "" ? x.child3OldId == child3Id : x.child4OldId == child4Id)))))
+                                // .Where(x => rootId == "" ? true : (child1Id == "" ? x.rootOldId == rootId : (child2Id == "" ? x.child1OldId == child1Id : (child3Id == "" ? x.child2OldId == child2Id : (child4Id == "" ? x.child3OldId == child3Id : x.child4OldId == child4Id)))))
                                 .Select(p => new
                                 {
                                     p.Id,